| Author | Message | Stephen Perrera 
Posts: 823 Since: 5/27/2008

|  6/4/2008 10:28:48 PM 
I would have to say that using slag as a base is a little different than using it in a mix.
|  |
| Ray Darrah 
Posts: 1411 Since: 2/18/2008
|  6/7/2008 7:57:48 AM 
quote: Ray, you know what slag is. The remnants of iron ore processing. Its a glass like composite that is crushed and added not unlike fly ash. Has been used for many years in concrete with ratios like I listed above. It does the same thing as fly ash...like making it flow better, makes concrete less permeable and all that stuff.
Makes me wonder why its any different than fly ash or why there has not been any problems with this type concrete and floorcovering adhesives.
That reminds me. Didn't you write a book about concrete and flooring failures awhile back? Wasn't this in your book as well? Can you send me a copy or let us know where we can buy one?
Perhaps you could post it on floorreports.
Wrote a Book on COncrete? Yes, Selva has the only copy, other than Gina.
It needed to be completed, but written in 1995.
|  |
| Stephen Perrera 
Posts: 823 Since: 5/27/2008

|  6/7/2008 11:33:32 AM 
I thought you sold it to the mills?
|  |
| Ray Darrah 
Posts: 1411 Since: 2/18/2008
|  6/7/2008 1:24:26 PM 
Book never sold. Gave it to Tim Smith in print form. That is how Gina got a copy... Then my computer crashed and I lost it. Dummy me did not keep disc copy...
Could not get a copy back from FCITS.. oh well... life is just too short to worry about such issues of the past.
|  |
| Stephen Perrera 
Posts: 823 Since: 5/27/2008

|  6/7/2008 7:15:10 PM 
OK then, your the concrete expert here. I know you've taken classes at the concrete institute.
So tell us what the difference is between flyash and slag in concrete.
|  |
| Stephen Perrera 
Posts: 823 Since: 5/27/2008

|  6/7/2008 10:44:15 PM 
I think your holding out on us Raymond.
|  |
| Darian Brown 
Posts: 712 Since: 2/5/2008
|  6/8/2008 11:27:41 AM 
The fly ash from a given power plant may vary with time depending on many factors such as changes in the burning conditions, or source and composition of coal. Variations in the fly ash
Here a good read enjoy.
http://www.nrcan.gc.ca/mms/canmet-mtb/mmsl-lmsm/enviro/reports/FABP-EN.pdf
|  |
| Ray Darrah 
Posts: 1411 Since: 2/18/2008
|  6/8/2008 2:54:11 PM 
quote: This issue started because LEEDS accepted an arbitrary number (40% fly-ash content in slabs) in offering LEEDS credits for construction companies.
The problem that those in-the-know are aware of is that no adhesive will stick to a slab that has that much fly-ash content (regardless of being broom-swept or not) and that applies to thin-set as well.
This translates into an industry nightmare where any flooring that has to be glued or thin-setted will not stay down.
This is why the controlled pours are going to be done in Dalton. To determine how much fly-ash is too much.
Stay tuned...
By the way, great article Stephen.
Has "Broom" finish been tested? If so, where can we see these tests?
|  |
| Stephen Perrera 
Posts: 823 Since: 5/27/2008

|  6/8/2008 8:44:29 PM 
I'm going to spend some time tomorrow asking question to the experts avbout this. Look for my questions on the aggregate forum.
Today I floated in my pool half the day, Corona in hand. First time I had a chance this season to float. Nice music in the system, cold brewski and a hot babe. Life is good!
|  |
| Stephen Perrera 
Posts: 823 Since: 5/27/2008

|  6/12/2008 10:23:48 AM 
Gee, almost went of the top page here on this topic.
I finally posed the question on the aggregate forum and got this:
http://www.aggregateresearch.com/forum/viewmessage.aspx?MID=5800
Now I went to Lew's website and looked for the April, 08 issue and could not open it for some reason. Lew's CFR is not posted here either.
SP
Last Edited 6/12/2008 10:25:32 AM
|  |
| Roger Gerber 
Posts: 327 Since: 3/17/2008
|  6/12/2008 3:22:36 PM 
"Now I went to Lew's website and looked for the April, 08 issue and could not open it for some reason. Lew's CFR is not posted here either."
Stephen, go to the first post in this thread, the link is still good.
|  |
| David Kern 
Posts: 518 Since: 2/20/2008
|  6/12/2008 3:40:24 PM  The CFR can be found...
From our main page, simply click the down arrow under 'The Commercial Flooring Report' link to select the report you want to view. The April issue is there.
|  |
| Darian Brown 
Posts: 712 Since: 2/5/2008
|  8/9/2008 6:15:45 PM 
Any up dates as of yet?
Seen this on you tube. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDvaPf2FCwI
|  |
| Selva Lee Tucker 
Posts: 634 Since: 5/25/2008
|  8/10/2008 2:06:41 AM 
Darin, flyash in concrete is "encased", would not worry about it, again, been in there for years, if you talk to the old concrete guys, you will find that in the last 15 to 20 years, they have cleaned up their product a lot,,,I mean, they used to use all kinds of "bad stuff" as fillers, and never a problem,,,, in our industry, there are many "hot button Issues" "industry leaders" make up to keep their names out front,,,,before all the VOCs and EPA regulations, the adhesives would stick to anything, but of course, they would also burn out our lungs,
it is a trade off, you are not exposed to as much harmful chemicals, but, you have more problems, healthy lungs or flooring that sticks without problems,,,,,I take the healthy lungs myself,
Last Edited 8/10/2008 2:10:50 AM
|  |
| Darian Brown 
Posts: 712 Since: 2/5/2008
|  8/10/2008 1:28:20 PM 
Darin, flyash in concrete is "encased", would not worry about it,again, been in there for years,
I agree Lee, it’s “encased”, so are you saying there is no need to grind humps out of a floor, or there is no need for relieve cut in floor. How about concrete is so hard that it will never crack.
if you talk to the old concrete guys, you will find that in the last 15 to 20 years, they have cleaned up their product a lot,,,I mean, they used to use all kinds of "bad stuff" as fillers, and never a problem,,,,
Lee your right again concrete is prefect and always has been.
in our industry, there are many "hot button Issues" "industry leaders" make up to keep their names out front,,,,before all the VOCs and EPA regulations, the adhesives would stick to anything, but of course, they would also burn out our lungs,
Lee I agree things need to be address up front and a lot sooner than they are. I also believe each of you men that are voicing your options are industry leaders, how you use that power is up to you. it is a trade off, you are not exposed to as much harmful chemicals, but, you have more problems, healthy lungs or flooring that sticks without problems,,,,,I take the healthy lungs myself,
Lee I agree again, but as you will know every thing is a trade off, lungs, cancer, etc. choose your on poison. Safety should be higher on the list for workers and occupants of the buildings.
|  |
| Selva Lee Tucker 
Posts: 634 Since: 5/25/2008
|  8/10/2008 4:39:40 PM 
"" quote: Darin, flyash in concrete is "encased", would not worry about it,again, been in there for years,
I agree Lee, it's 'encased', so are you saying there is no need to grind humps out of a floor, or there is no need for relieve cut in floor. How about concrete is so hard that it will never crack. """
I hope you are using a dustless system, no matter what is in it, OSHA regs require it if for no other reason
""""if you talk to the old concrete guys, you will find that in the last 15 to 20 years, they have cleaned up their product a lot,,,I mean, they used to use all kinds of "bad stuff" as fillers, and never a problem,,,,
Lee your right again concrete is prefect and always has been"""".
No, it is not perfect, just better than then in terms of what they are putting in it,,,in "past days", lot of "stuff" would go into a batch,,,just cleaner now to help us with our "new" adhesives
""""in our industry, there are many "hot button Issues" "industry leaders" make up to keep their names out front,,,,before all the VOCs and EPA regulations, the adhesives would stick to anything, but of course, they would also burn out our lungs,
Lee I agree things need to be address up front and a lot sooner than they are. I also believe each of you men that are voicing your options are industry leaders, how you use that power is up to you. """"
I am not, repeat, not, an industry leader, the ones who "tag" themselves as "industry leaders" are not the leaders, just egoistical greedy people wanting your dollar,,,I have never asked anyone for money, well, I really would like one of those BYK full spectrum gloss finish thickness meters, only about 5000 if you guys don't mind chipping in for one for me,, """"it is a trade off, you are not exposed to as much harmful chemicals, but, you have more problems, healthy lungs or flooring that sticks without problems,,,,,I take the healthy lungs myself,
Lee I agree again, but as you will know every thing is a trade off, lungs, cancer, etc. choose your on poison. Safety should be higher on the list for workers and occupants of the buildings.
"""""""
I agreed with your last statement, as I do with most of it,,, which is now, instead of worrying about me and my dream meter, lets talk about you grinding concrete, do you have the dustless system, if not, I will contribute 10 to 15 toward getting you one,,,concrete dust will eat out your lungs and cause cancer, bad stuff
Last Edited 8/10/2008 4:41:58 PM
|  |
| Darian Brown 
Posts: 712 Since: 2/5/2008
|  8/11/2008 12:50:18 AM 
Yea I got a small one it’s all right. I would like one off them big commercial one though there nice. I see this all the time they just don’t know.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Kk57X-XNXE&feature=related
|  |
| Selva Lee Tucker 
Posts: 634 Since: 5/25/2008
|  8/11/2008 1:04:20 AM 
ok, there are systems, that can, make you tons of money you just have not explored yet, there are the ride on floor strippers, big money there, there are the big grinding machines, dustless, that are used every day on construction sites by floor people, first, contact your local distributors, and see what they have, then, contact some of the smaller commercial contractors, or the lager stores, and offer the services,,,,only, do not go in asking for work, go in, like, you are doing them a favor, which you are, offering them a chance to get the job done, at your price, have fun
|  |
| Darian Brown 
Posts: 712 Since: 2/5/2008
| | Selva Lee Tucker 
Posts: 634 Since: 5/25/2008
|  8/11/2008 6:16:17 PM 
they are looking for the cheap, keep working the contractors,,,,small contractors need that kind of work done,,,the big ones will already have the equipment,
otherwise, go directly to the building contractors remodeling, did you find the contractors who specialize in remodeling buildings?
or, otherwise, I will shut up now,,,,maybe I am wrong about it if you have tried,,,,
|  |
| Displaying page 6 of 7 Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Next |
|